Road diet (roadway reconfiguration)

Road Infrastructure
Vulnerable Road Users, General Population
Speed and Aggressive Driving, Road Infrastructure
Road Infrastructure
Yes

More than 80% of pedestrians hit by vehicles traveling at 40 mph or faster will die, while less than 10% will die when hit at 20 mph or less. (Federal Highway Administration, 2012).

Road diets are used to reconfigure existing roadways to better accommodate pedestrians, cyclists, and public transit while continuing to adequately accommodate passenger vehicle traffic. Road diet projects usually involve the conversion of a four lane undivided roadway to a two lane roadway with either a center median (painted or raised) and left turn lanes at intersections or a two-way center left turn lane.

Roadways with Average Daily Traffic (ADT) of 20,000 or less may be good candidates for a road diet and should be evaluated for feasibility. Roads with 15,000 ADT or less have experienced good results in the areas of safety, operations, and livability. Driveway density, transit routes, the number and design of intersections along the corridor, as well as operational characteristics are considerations that should be evaluated before a road diet is implemented (Federal Highway Administration, 2012).

It is prudent to conduct an evaluation study on the implementation of a road diet prior to road reconstruction or overlay projects. The effects of the proposed changes should be analysed and input from community stakeholders should be obtained to ensure that the appropriate elements are included in the project. Improvements to intersection turn lanes, signing, pavement markings, traffic control devices, transit stops, and pedestrian and bicyclist facilities may be necessary to achieve the objective. The Federal Highway Administration noted that the classic four-to-three-lane road diet is very compatible with single-lane roundabouts.

When properly applied, road diets provide benefits to pedestrians, cyclists, and motorists. The resulting benefits include reduced vehicle speeds, improved mobility and access, reduced collisions and injuries, and improved livability and quality of life. According to the Federal Highway Administration (2012), when modified from four travel lanes to two travel lanes with a two-way left-turn lane, roadways have experienced a 29% reduction in all roadway crashes. The benefits to pedestrians include reduced crossing distance and fewer midblock crossing locations, which account for more than 70% of pedestrian fatalities.

The Oregon Department of Transportation cited the results of a before and after study conducted on 3 road diets in San Francisco, in which the San Francisco Transportation Authority found a reduction in speeds of 4%-14%. They also found that midblock crashes decreased by 84%.

Lyles et al. (2012) studied road diets in various locations in Michigan and found that crashes in all areas where diets were implemented decreased by an average of 5%. The authors also found that the implementation of road diets on roads with average daily traffic that exceeded 10,000 vehicles and peak hourly traffic volumes that exceeded 1,000 vehicles resulted in significant delays.

Gates et al (2007) conducted research to determine the safety and operational effects of converting four-lane undivided roadways to three-lanes with a center two-way left turn lane in Minnesota. Several statistical analyses using both Empirical Bayes and Grouped Comparison procedures were performed using multiple years of before-and-after speed and/or crash data from nine road diet sites in Minnesota. The range of crash reductions varied from 37.3%-54.3% among the sites. Non-injury and right angle crashes were reduced by 45.7% and 37%, respectively. Injury crashes showed negligible change. Reductions in the mean and 85th percentile speeds after the conversions were observed at each of the six sites for which speed data were available, with a median reduction in both the mean and 85th speeds of 2 mph (Gates et al, 2007).

Rosales, J. A. (2006) summarized the results of six case studies of road diets in the United States, Canada, and New Zealand. Following the implementation of the road diets, the number of crashes decreased by 10% to 53% and the cases that tracked changes in vehicle speed experienced traffic speed decreases of 18%-32%. Aggressive speeding decreased by 5% and 76%, respectively, at the two case study locations where this information was documented. Three of the studies noted that pedestrian and cyclist safety had improved.

Rocchi et al. (2011) studied the effects of six recent road diet projects in British Columbia. The sites were analyzed using simple before-and-after methods, in addition to comparison with faraway controls. Collision reductions ranging from 23% to 78% were observed at four of the sites. However, collision increases resulted at two of the sites. The authors of this study indicated that site-specific issues at these two locations (traffic volumes that exceeded the recommended range and growth in development) may have contributed to the results.

Evidence